So, huge shout out to the OP and everyone in between. It turned out wonderfully. The shrimp were good, nice smoke, sweetness. The mini lobsters were outstanding! Very succulent, bursting with flavor.
The lobsters were previously frozen mini 4 ouncers at $5 a piece that they have at my local market. I got five of em and threw two in with the shrimp. Wow!
Some comments...
1. I don't really like Italian Dressing very much and I knew this going in but I didn't want to change the key ingredient in the sauce my first time out.
2. I will use perhaps a combination of more butter and some olive oil instead of the Italian Dressing next time.
3. I was too careful with the salt and would add some more.
4. Add more pepper.
5. I would up the ante to TWO BULBS of garlic.
6. The GRAPE 3 oz wood chunks were the perfect match for this dish. Nice sweet, deep smokey flavor.
7. Hickory, or any similar strong wood, at 3 oz would have ruined this dish...I'd use a fruit wood.
Once again, thanks everyone.
Cooking time 225F @ 1 hour exact with other specs in my previous post was all perfect.