All good points. My suggestions were just that, suggestions for making the smoker more flexible and allow more multi-tasking.
Excellent point that if the box maxes out at 350, and therefore the analog controller going up to 350 would be a bad idea for that reason. So make it 325 then. Issue negated?
I'm not sure I buy the statement that it would be bad to allow higher temps because people will use them incorrectly. That is what instructions and forums like this are for, to help people that do things wrong and offer suggestions that can help their next smoke be better.
I'm also a little dubious that allowing an extra 75 degrees of heat would result in excess "wear and tear".
I guess I am just thinking about this whole thing as adding flexibility and more uses for the smoker. Most people try to reduce the number of uni-taskers in their homes. Why would I want to dirty up my oven or grill just to finish off my meal when it could be done in the same vessel with only one clean-up?
I'll definitely agree that the vast majority of smokes will be less than 250. I guess I just don't see the cons of allowing an extra 75 degrees being all that negative compared to the pros.
If "most" people will never smoke anything over 250, why do the overwhelming majority of Auber users add the bypass? If you don't need to go above 250, adding the bypass is really unnecessary right? Is it because most people don't use an Auber? Well, maybe. I guess I would buy that to a point. But it sure seems like the Auber is really becoming more and more mainstream here than it used to be and I don't remember anyone saying that they are going to use the Auber but skip doing the bypass.
I kind of get the feeling that my suggestions were interpreted as an attack on Steve or his company that needed to be defended. But that could not be further from the truth or how I meant for it to come out anyhow. It feels weird for me to be disagreeing with my mentors (Old Sarge and Divot), but I guess we all have our own opinions right?
As anyone who has read any of my posts knows, I am a Smokin-It company-man all the way.
Maybe this isn't a feasible idea or worth doing anything with. If that is the result, I am totally OK with that. I just feel good that it was brought up and we had a healthy discussion on the pros and cons.