RG said:
Now y'all tell me ;D
My magic number for butts has always been 197° but I have pulled them off sooner.
Hehe. Funny how we all seem to have a "magic number!" I would suspect it's because we remember that "perfect" butt, brisket, or whatever, that came off at that "magic" temp and was perfect!
Funny thing with butts: I've experimented from 190 to 205, and have decided that pretty much
anywhere in the 190's is good! Here's what I found: Once you go through the stall, which is where all the magic happens (as far as tenderizing), if you hit the 190's, you won't tell much difference in the results. The bone pulls clean, with just a little wiggle, and the meat is moist and tender. I actually believe that going past 200 is detrimental. The meat seems to be drier in the high 190s to over 200. I never go past 195 on butts now, and am very pleased with the results!
So, I found your magic temp of 197 kind of funny.
A few degrees, one way or the other, doesn't make a hill of beans in BBQ. Try pulling one at, say, 194, and see if you can tell the difference. 8)