Questioning Temp Probe

S

S and M

New member
This is my first smoke and I have two 3.5 lb pork butts in at 225.  It has been about 6.5 hours and the IT is reading 154.  Its a brand new sensor (it appears to correlate with outside temperature this a.m.)  I have no other thermometer at this time.  Do I trust it or run to the store and grab a manual one and stick it in?    Just  a little concerned here.      LOL    Thanks
 
One of the 2 temps are not correct so I'd spend the $8 on a manual probe.  Either that or pull one out for physical testing.

p.s. you are at a point where it would'nt hurt to turn up the heat either.
 
Just for Clarification:  Its a single probe.
When I was setting up this morning the single temp probe measured outside air temperature correctly.  Anyhow, I'm off to the store to get a manual one.  Thanks for your response!
 
And for further clarification, I'm not saying the 154 is off, it might be the 225 but unless the meat was still partially frozen, I can't visualize a 3.5 lbs piece of meat sitting at that temp 6 hours into a smoke.  I cook 8 lbs pieces of meat in that time with a crutch. 
 
I don't know. It doesn't really sound off to me. I have heard of people here smoking small butts and it taking just as long as the larger ones.

I have a feeling that purchasing the manual probe is going to be a waste of money except for providing some piece of mind.
 
NDKoze said:
I don't know. It doesn't really sound off to me. I have heard of people here smoking small butts and it taking just as long as the larger ones.

I have a feeling that purchasing the manual probe is going to be a waste of money except for providing some piece of mind.
Click to expand...
Which is why I think he posted.  :-\
IMO, waiting 8 hours for a 3.5 lbs pork butt is ludicrous. 
 
Seems like a long time, but in certain circumstances it can take longer than expected.....a lean high-moisture piece of butt in a relatively low moisture smoker can take a long time to finish.
What most folks don't understand is that the 225 degree set temperature isn't the actual smoking/cooking temperature if evaporative cooling is in play.
 
There is a point at which being lazy is trumped by being hungry.  Foil the darn thing and turn the heat up. 
 
SuperDave said:
There is a point at which being lazy is trumped by being hungry.  Foil the darn thing and turn the heat up.
Click to expand...

Lazy?
C'mon!!!
Be nice!
I see this as someone learning his smoker and thermometers.
 
DiggingDogFarm said:
SuperDave said:
There is a point at which being lazy is trumped by being hungry.  Foil the darn thing and turn the heat up.
Click to expand...

Lazy?
C'mon!!!
Be nice!
I see this as someone learning his smoker and thermometers.
Click to expand...

+1!  Everyone has to feel their way through the first smoke or two! 
 
I typically strongly avoid the urge to turn the heat up to try to push it along, especially with Boston Butts. If its not going to be ready for my meal, I'll order a pizza and stay the course. Then vacuum seal when it is done and enjoy another day.

I think your results will suffer by pushing it, and I would rather have great results tomorrow than less than stellar results on time for my meal today.

Just my opinion.
 
You guys seem awful set in your ways.  Watch some bbq professionals in competition.  It is a lot less complicated than you guys make out.  And "Lazy" was Tony's terms, I used them because not tending the smoker is only good to a point but useless if one doesn't get to eat dinner.
 
I'm not set in my ways so much as trying to answer the actual question.  8)
" I have no other thermometer at this time.  Do I trust it or run to the store and grab a manual one and stick it in?"
Well of course you can crank the damn temperature up!!!!!!!!  ::)
 
Thanks everybody for your support.  It is very appreciated as I'm just barely getting started.  I went out and got a $6.00 thermometer from the store and it basically matched the digital probe.  The SI #2 continued to cycle  as I assume it does.  After 11 hours the pork butts reached an IT of 195.  It was way later than planned, and the family was ready to settle for any food of any kind, but they agreed it was really good.  Looking forward to reading more from this forum and getting ready for my next smoke.  Biggest take aways were:  Start early, relax and let it run its course and know there are folks out there who will help answer questions/concerns if you get stuck.

Thanks again
 
NDKoze said:
I don't know. It doesn't really sound off to me. I have heard of people here smoking small butts and it taking just as long as the larger ones.

I have a feeling that purchasing the manual probe is going to be a waste of money except for providing some piece of mind.
Click to expand...

Well, I normally wouldn't say I told you so but... ;)

Those smaller roasts just have a mind of their own sometimes.

In the future I would recommend trying to find a 7-10 pounder.
 
Gregg's sure right about size - it does matter! ;)  I once smoked a 4 lb corned beef brisket that took 11 hours!  I wouldn't have believed it, had I not lived it!  And that was after bumping the temp to 240!  Larger cuts cook so much better.  I think the little roasts shrink-up too much, and the muscle gets tight and dense, and increases the cook time.  Just my theory...
 
Reading this conversation just brought the lyrics from "Baby Got Back" into my mind... "I like big butts and I cannot lie". Damn this thread!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

M
Hello from Connecticut
Replies
3
Views
425
Hank R
Hank R
bocaboy
BBQ Boston Butt ala Tuffy Stone
Replies
2
Views
1K
old sarge
old sarge
Brewsmoker
2D first smoke
Replies
2
Views
689
LarryD
L
V
This isn't starting as planned
Replies
8
Views
1K
swthorpe
S
J
Another white smoke and creosote post Need help
Replies
1
Views
796
old sarge
old sarge
Back
Top