Mac and Cheese

I tried the recipe at the beginning of this thread and i must have used too much wood/too long.  3 hours at 225 with a mix of hickory and Apple was too smokey for me. May try again with less wood/less time
 
The last time I did this recipe I set for 230F and about 2 hours of smoke.  I used 3oz of cherry, which is a milder/sweeter wood than hickory.  I would suggest increasing your temp slightly on the next try, and go for 2 hours rather than 3.  If you remove it at 2 and give a taste test, if you think it needs more time, then you could put in back in the smoker.
 
So I made this again tonight.  I used the recipe at the link and it turned out 1000% better.  1oz Peach smoked 240F for just about 2 hours.  Everyone loved this time around and my wife asked for this for an upcoming potluck.

 
Way to go!  I have used this recipe three or four times now, and never left overs!  I don't know what it is about the recipe, but it comes out really cheesy and creamy, and people rave about it.   
 
swthorpe said:
Way to go!  I have used this recipe three or four times now, and never left overs!  I don't know what it is about the recipe, but it comes out really cheesy and creamy, and people rave about it. 
As good as it is the first time around, you got to make enough to try "leftovers".  The flavor gets even better over night. 
 
Just pulled Jeff Phillips' mac & cheese from the #2. It was in for 3 hours with 4 racks of baby backs that are still smoking. I used 3 ounces of apple wood. Going to let the ribs go another 2 hours and then hit em with Jeff's sauce. Don't know if I can stay out of the mac & cheeses until the ribs are ready!
 
Tony here is a pic of the mac and cheese. More pics when I pull the ribs.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20150110_144413_953~2.jpg
    IMG_20150110_144413_953~2.jpg
    613.9 KB · Views: 362
Matt,


Your Mac N Cheese looks like it turned out better than mine. Eat it while it's hot! Let us all know the outcome of the taste, flavors, and moisture content! I feel mine was a bit dry but I didn't dig into it until about 5 hours after it was out of the smoker.
 
The last time I made this it was too dry too.

But I had smoked it, cooled it and reheated, which is what caused my problem.
 
NDKoze said:
The last time I made this it was too dry too.

But I had smoked it, cooled it and reheated, which is what caused my problem.

I think Jeff's Mac N Cheese is probably best served right away out of the smoker. We did cool and reheat ours as well but added some more half and half or milk to the reheating process in order to help bring up some moisture. In fact I still have some of this leftover in my fridge. Maybe I'll try to reheat more tomorrow (I should probably hurry since it has been in the fridge just over a week now).
 
My experience has been to not cook it too much. This needs to be undercooked when taking it out of the smoker. Like a pudding consistency.  Let it rest and it will continue cooking and set. Otherwise it will dry out very quickly after you take it out. Cheese gets extremely hot and cools off and solidifys in short order. When we want a piece another day from the fridge, we nuke it on high so the cheese quickly melts. If it was cooked properly it will still reheat fairly well.
 
The mac and cheese was excellent. It smoked for 3 hours with the baby back ribs. It was not dried out and I attribute that to the apple juice that was in Miss Lilly's Flavor Savor adding some moisture to the #2. I removed the mac and cheese from the smoker and covered the pan with foil while letting the ribs cook another 2 hours. When I opened the smoker to brush the ribs with Jeff Phillips' BBQ sauce, I placed the mac and cheese back in the smoker for a 1/2 hour on the top most shelf to heat it back up for serving. Everyone over for the game yesterday liked the mac & cheese and I had no leftovers.
 
Even well cooked pasta will continue to absorb moisture so baked mac & cheese continues to absorb the liquid the longer it is smoked or baked.  If you viewed similar recipes for stove top mac & cheese vs. oven, one would see twice the liquid ratio.  Smoked or oven mac and cheese is almost soup when it goes in.  One experiment I did was to lightly smoke my sauce and then mix it with the noodles.  I like really creamy mac & cheese so I thought it was a hit.  Others like a top crusty style so the standard method works better for that. 
 
Baby backs turned out good Bob. They were moist and everyone loved them. The only change I would make to the ribs would be to sear them on a high heat grill after pulling them from the smoker to give them a nice bark.
 
Back
Top