1st Attempt at Beef Jerky

Okay, time to report back...

I smoked my first batch of beef jerky over the weekend.  I started with a 2.5-pound beef round steak, cut into thin strips (about 1/8 of an inch).  Marinated overnight in the recipe Joe supplied, omitting the liquid smoke for obvious reasons.

Smoked the meat at 180° for a little over two hours without the Jerky Dryer attachment, then placed the attachment directly over the smoke hole (it is designed to simply rest flush on top of the smoker) and continued smoking at about 140° for an additional six hours.

At about the four-hour mark, I opened the smoker and rotated the racks (bringing the lower rack to the top, the middle rack to the bottom, and the upper rack to the middle) so as to ensure even cooking.

After six hours with the Jerky Dryer attached, I removed the jerky and let it cool for an hour or so.  Afterwards, I tore the jerky into smaller strips and stored overnight in an airtight container.

Overall, it came out very well, and pretty much everyone who tried it has enjoyed it.

Here are my observations and lessons learned:

• The James Jerky dryer worked perfectly.  Drew the moisture out of the smoker, ran for several hours with no issue.  Works as advertised, and a great buy.  :)

• Due to the fact that the jerky cooks at a significantly lower temperature than other foods, I noticed throughout the process that the wood chunks I used (pecan and apple combined) simply didn't produce as much smoke as usual.  In fact, when I opened the smoke box afterwards, one of the chunks of pecan was still largely intact.  It was singed, but certainly not "depleted" as chunks usually are after making ribs, brisket, etc.

• The consistency and texture of the jerky is perfect.

• The flavor is excellent.  Sweet, smoky, but not overpowering.  You can still taste the meat underneath, which is the whole point.

• The only real issue is that the jerky actually dried out a bit too much.  Some of the pieces are almost brittle, and all of them are a bit drier than what I usually like.  I don't think this had anything to do with the equipment, but rather the amount of time I smoked it.  For future jerky batches, I will designate a "test piece" that I can check at various intervals to ensure I'm removing the jerky at the right moment.

So overall, not a bad first try.  I will definitely be using the Jerky Dryer to make more batches.  I'm going to experiment with various marinades, woods (maybe chips instead of chunks?), and smoking times.  I can say, however, that if you are on the fence about picking up the JJD, take the plunge.  Making jerky is one of the primary reasons I got the smoker in the first place, and I was not disappointed at all.

Thanks!

  - Phil


 
Hey Phil,

Thanks for posting your detailed review and feedback from your first attempt at beef jerky.  I also highly recommend the fan, it is well built, quiet operation and well worth the money.

I noticed that you started with a temp of 180 which may have resulted in some pieces being dry and brittle, however I started with a temperature of 160 a yet I still had a few pieces that turned out brittle because I left them a bit too long.  What I found is that you really have to keep an eye on them near the end because some pieces are done before others and it is touch and go from there.

At the very least, I am glad to hear that your first attempt was successful. 
 
Hey Phil & Tony (Smokester) - Thanks for the really good details on the JD!  I'll be ordering one soon.  I like a little thicker jerky, starting with 1/4" slices so I end up with 1/8" strips done.  Any ideas on how thicker slices will effect the drying time?  Seems like thicker, consistent, slices might even-out some of the problems concerning some pieces drying faster....dunno, just guessing. 
 
Hey DM,

You may be onto something with the thicker slices which I may give a try during my next round.  I did two rounds with the first turning out better than the second, but I believe it was a timing issue because I left the 2nd round in the smoker for a bit too long. 

I also just read an article which stated that the temp should be set to 150 - 170.  180 or over will start to cook the meat.

http://www.thebbqguru.net/jerky%20page.html



 
That's cool, Smokester!  I just know the thicker slices work a lot better in my dehydrator, so I figured that would translate well to the Smokin-It (plus, I just like the chewy slices of thick jerky). :P
 
I have a tip for ya if your jerky comes out too dry. Just re soak it in a marinade. Then dry it again to the texture that you want. I have done this quite a few times doing jerky in a stick burner or the oven.
 
Wow, what a great tip you provided to save your jerky.  Definitely something to remember.  thanks for your feedback sts3d.
 
Got the dryer a couple of days ago & would like to give it a try.  What is the preferrable cut to use?  I see some useing flank, sirloin tip, etc. 

Tony, with more of us getting the dryer, "Jerky" might need its own tab.
 
Good suggestion, Walt!  I personally like sirloin roast (sirloin tip, sirloin), but I've found top round roasts that are pretty lean, too.  The best jerky meat, in my opinion, is very lean.  The sirloins and rounds tend to have much less marbling than others.  It doesn't really matter about the "tenderness," since you're turning it into leather anyways...just the "leanness."  Fat in jerky = bad!
 
Back
Top