Smokin-It Model 2 or 3 Help Me Decide

harpcustom

New member
Hello to all... I am wanting a smoker obviously :)  I will mostly smoke packer briskets.  I am wanting to know if I smoke 2 briskets at a time will they fit in the model 2 or will I be better off with the model 3?  Any insight from owners is very appreciated.  I mostly just want to make the right purchase the first time and not regret wishing I had gone larger.  Thanks for your comments.
-Troy
 
Troy,

I believe the #2 will accommodate 2 briskets, although I have not smoked briskets in my #2.  I have easily smoked 4 racks of BB ribs on 3 racks (of the 4 that come with the #2).  I have also smoked two whole 6# chickens side by side in the #2.    If you can handle the price of the #3 over the #2 (and shipping costs), then the larger unit would provide more options.  As they say, you can always smoke less in a larger unit, but not more in a smaller unit!

 
GO FOR THE #3 IF YOU CAN AFFORD IT.... " I would rather have the room and not need it, than need the room and not have it."
 
Thanks for your reply.  I ordered the Model 3.  I figured... buy once.  It is nice to have the extra space and not use it than wish I had the space and didn't have it.  Thanks, I am excited.
 
Congrats on your decision, Troy!  You'll have good times ahead.  We look forward to hearing about your success stories!
 
I will keep you posted when it arrives.  Years ago I use to have a crappy propane walmart smoker that was terrible.  However, I put a lot of time in smoking brisket and I had good results with a lot of effort so I am for sure looking forward to this smoker.  I will shoot a photo and put it up here when ready. 

I ordered it today and Steve shipped it today.  He even threw in a free cover for it.  I can't wait to smoke Briskets again and learn to do other meats also.

 
Troy
the #3 does a great job on brisket. I have smoked a handful of briskets and they all came out great.
I hope you get your smoker soon. Maybe you can post your brisket recipe soon. Always looking for more smoking knowledge.
 
TRIMMING AND PREPARATION
I trim most of the fat off the brisket.  I leave about 1/8 - 1/4.  I don't go into the crevices (between point and flat) very deeply at all.  I will try and get most of the membrane type fat off where possible to allow for a better tasting texture, rendering, and seasoning (rub, marinade, glaze) penetration and build-up).  This is not a point to get to anal about.  Just leave a bit of fat on to self-baste, but not enough to bother you while slicing and eating.  After it is cooked it all taste crusty and great!  You might take a LOT of fat off your brisket.  Maybe 1/4 of its entire weight.  Oh well.  That is the way they come.
This process can take a bit of time and a lot of fat will come off, but it is worth it.
 
COOKING IN A SMOKER.
I always cook a whole packer cut brisket if possible.  I smoke for 1.25 hours per pound.  I rotate and baste the meat ever hour and check wood chip supply and water supply. After 6-8 hours I then stop the smoke and wrap the brisket well in heavy duty foil.  I cook for an additional 4-8 hours depending on the size. I cook my briskets between 225-245 1.25 hours per pound.  I will start basting about half-way through the process and about every 60-90 minutes from that point on.  After the last 4-8 hours of cooking in the wrapped foil I take it out and wrap it in towels and place it in a cooler for 7-8 hours.  At that point I take it out and remove the foil and the brisket is very hot and ready to eat or prepare for refrigeration if needed.  The last part (with the cooler and towels) really softens the meat further.
 

TRIMMING AND SLICING
When you lay your brisket out to trim or slice for the first time simply push your finger into the middle the brisket a slight distance.  You will immediately detect which way the grain is going.  Then cut it opposite of that.  I then typically separate the flat from the point because their grains do run different directions and this gives me a chance to remove the fat in between.
 
Back
Top