Smoked Top Sirloin Roast

DivotMaker

New member
Did a cut I haven't done before this weekend - the Top Sirloin boneless "1/4 cut" roast, from Sam's.  This was a 10 lb sirloin, in the cryovac primal cut section at Sam's.  I've been eyeing these for awhile, but haven't tried one.  Not to be confused with the sirloin tip roast.  I believe this is the sirloin end of the beef clod, and it's a big hunk of roast!

Wish I would have done one of these long ago, as it was absolutely the best roast I've smoked!  This cut is truly the "poor man's prime rib!"  So incredibly tender and juicy, and full of flavor!

I started with my brisket injection:

1/2 cup beef broth
1/4 cup Worcestershire
2 tbsp crystal hot sauce
2 tbsp demerara sugar
1 tbsp salt
1/3 cup Full-flavor beer (or any "full-flavor" beer - it's for flavor, not alcohol.  I won't use "light" beer for this).

After injecting, it was coated with Jim Baldridge's Secret Seasoning, wrapped in plastic, and into the fridge for a long, happy-time, night's sleep!

I put it in the smoker Sunday at 10am, with water pans and 6 oz of Smokinlicious hickory.  The smoker was set to 210 for a low-temp smoke (the way I do prime rib), and the Auber set to finish at 128.  It took 5 hours to reach 128, and it was double-wrapped and placed in the cooler.

After a 1 hour rest, the roast was reverse-seared in a 500° oven for 8 minutes, then sliced.  As you can see by the pics, this method produces a beautiful medium-rare finish from edge to edge.  There is no gray edge, like you would get with a higher temp.  Beef can safely take a long, low smoke at this temp, but I'd never do it with chicken or pork!  The reverse-sear gives a nice crust, and doesn't effect that beautiful pink center.

I'll be doing more of these sirloins!  I may even dry-age one, just for fun! ;)

ps - the first pic is the roast right out of the smoker, ready to wrap, and before the final sear.
 

Attachments

  • TopSirloin1.jpg
    TopSirloin1.jpg
    69.2 KB · Views: 852
  • TopSirloinDone.jpg
    TopSirloinDone.jpg
    60.9 KB · Views: 880
  • TopSirloinDone2.jpg
    TopSirloinDone2.jpg
    46.7 KB · Views: 747
  • TopSirloinDone3.jpg
    TopSirloinDone3.jpg
    51.7 KB · Views: 910
swthorpe said:
Greg...did you notice if RD sells top sirloin or sirloin tip roasts?

Steve,

This was not on my radar, so I don't know, but I will check in a few weeks on my next visit!

Greg
 
Butcher in the house?  Be careful of tip roasts.  My experience with anything with the word "tip" associated with it is London broil lean and maybe best for jerky?  Not an expert but not a fan of tips.
 
swthorpe said:
Greg...did you notice if RD sells top sirloin or sirloin tip roasts?
Hey Steve, at the one in K.C. I was looking for Sirloin steaks which they had but you have to slice them and they were top sirloin. I also noticed they had the sirloin tip roasts but do not remember the price.
 
SuperDave said:
Butcher in the house?  Be careful of tip roasts.  My experience with anything with the word "tip" associated with it is London broil lean and maybe best for jerky?  Not an expert but not a fan of tips.

Not a tip roast, Greg, but a full top sirloin roast.  Wonderful cut of meat.
 
Looks good Tony. Last Sunday I smoked a 14lb Top Sirloin Butt that I picked up at Sam's
and It turned out great. Fork cutting tender, pink and juicy. Very delicious cut of meat.

It took about 5hrs. @ 225. Used 5oz. hickory.
 

Attachments

  • FullSizeRender.jpg
    FullSizeRender.jpg
    71.8 KB · Views: 574
  • IMG_0039.JPG
    IMG_0039.JPG
    60.3 KB · Views: 596
Yes I did forget to take pics when slicing and I am ashamed :(

Was in too much of a hurry to use my new PRO140 Vacuum sealer and forgot about pics, sorry.
 
Looks great, Don!  I, too, feel slighted at not having the "money" shot, but I understand! ;)  That is a great cut of meat!  I re-read the tag, at Sam's, and saw it was a "Top Sirloin Boneless, 1/4 Cut."  I'm now a big fan of this roast!
 
Hey Tony, as still trying to learn about different cuts of meats. And I love top sirloin steaks. Could this be sliced into say 3/4" or 1" steaks? Just curious as have been seeing some of these at Restaurant Depot. Going to take a pen and paper next trip to write down some of the large pieces of beef that I wish to ask you all about them and how they should be smoked or cooked. Thanks in advance.
 
Back
Top