Danny, you won't fit 3 in a #2. It's not about weight, but all about volume. Three butts are just too large to fit. I would recommend 2 and 1, in separate smokes, or 3 separate smokes. If you have a vacuum sealer, they reheat great! Even if you just double-wrap in HD foil, and keep all three in the fridge, you can reheat them on serving day. Logistically speaking, 3 just won't fit at once.