I am considering buying either an SI2 or an SI3. I am new to smoking and have done a lot of research and this smoker appears to be one of if not the best line on the market. I had been considering a Bradley but am concerned about what users have to say about them and the quality sounds much cheaper than one of the SI models. I can't find the difference between the 2 and 3 anywhere on the site any info would be appreciated. Thanks
#2 vs #3
- Thread starter jp
- Start date
cookingdude555
New member
I don't have either, I am waiting for the SI3 to come back in stock. The SI3 is just bigger. You can fit ribs and brisket in without having to cut them. You can just fit more. This is why I am waiting for the SI3 to come back in stock before placing my order. I see it like the large big green egg I bought six years ago. Eventually I wanted the extra large to fit more food. This time I am starting off with the size I want.
Libohunden
Member
cookingdude555 said:
That's basically why I got a #3 instead of a 2!
It's worth the wait! I used to smoke 6-8 times a year. Love it so much, I'm smoking once or twice a week.
I'd highly recommend the seafood rack. Smoked salmon and other fish is one of our favorites now.
Pork Belly
Moderator
You don't want a Bradley, I used a one for over a year before the owner needed it back. I put some wear on it. He didn't mind because I was supplying him with bacon and other treats. I bought the #3 because I wanted that extra space and larger element. I have no regrets. The extra cost between a #2 and #3 is quickly overcome when you realize the savings of not buying Bradley wood Pucks. An 8 hour smoke in a Bradley is about $8 that adds up quick.
DivotMaker
New member
You came to the right place, JP! The size really depends on your needs. If you want to smoke for lots of folks at one time, or need to do full packer-cut briskets and whole racks of ribs, the #3 is the way to go. The difference between the #2 and 3 is depth; 15" on the 2, and 20" on the 3. 5" may not seem like a lot, but for the large cuts, its everything. I, personally, use the #2, but only smoke for 3 on a regular basis. While I would like to have a #3, it doesn't fit into my needs. I find the #2 perfect for my needs, but everyone has their own needs/wants. The 3s will be back in stock soon, and they now come with handles! 
